The Not-So-Odd Story Behind the Midwest’s Odd Food Creations

A salad of cool whip, pineapple juice and pistachio pudding; a casserole topped with tater tots; chili over spaghetti noodles — these foods are often named as staples of the Midwest’s peculiar culinary repertoire. Yet the food people choose to eat tells a story, and understanding the context behind the Midwest’s stranger meals yields insight into oft-forgotten facets of the region’s identity. Graphics by Sasha Borislow for Midstory.

Despite being America’s Breadbasket, the Midwest is not typically known for its nuanced culinary pursuits. Google it, and you’ll find lists like “9 Gross Recipes Your Midwestern Aunt Wants You to Try” or “10 Midwestern Foods That Are Strange & Confusing to Everyone Else.” Try an image search, and you’ll see curious depictions of dessert salads, Cincinnati Chili or Minnesota Hot Dishes. 

But whether you’re a lover or hater of such concoctions, the novel flavor combinations and peculiar textures found in decidedly Midwestern cuisine tell a deeper story — an edible manifestation of historical, economic and social circumstances that have shaped the region as we know it today. 

Midwestern cooking is generally characterized by modest, hearty meals that often incorporate dairy products and local produce, such as stews, casseroles and pot roasts. Look a little harder, and you can also find famed local delicacies, such as toasted ravioli from St. Louis or Chicago-style hot dogs. This division of dishes can be more eccentric, combining sweet and salty (see North Dakotan chippers) and incorporating an excessive amount of toppings. 

But according to food historian and author Cynthia Clampitt, much of the history behind Midwestern cooking can be attributed to just two things: “what’s available and who came.” In other words, it’s about what ingredients were prevalent during periods of change and which groups of people were calling the region home.

During World War II, the Midwest was burdened by the lasting effects of the Great Depression and a reduced male working-age population. Housewives had little in their pantries but many mouths to feed. It was during these economically turbulent times that foods like hotdishes and desperation pies integrated into Midwestern cuisine. 

A starchy mix of ground beef, canned vegetables, soup and tater tots, hotdishes were a saving grace for home cooks. With these meals, a few servings worth of ground beef could be dressed and stretched to feed a large family. 

“If you’ve got to serve a bunch of kids or a large group of farmers, you make casseroles. You don’t make individual plated meals,” Clampitt said.

A slice of sugar-butter pie — filled solely with sugar, butter and cream — or classic vinegar pie may not sound the most appetizing, but these desserts were a way to satisfy cravings when the economic situations of most households were not so sweet. 

Outside the context of economic hardships, the lack of agricultural advancements we enjoy the fruit of today meant crops were seasonally restricted. Fresh fruits and vegetables were not always available, so home cooks made do; in pies, crackers replaced the texture of apples and vinegar replaced the acidity of lemons.  

Some Midwestern food classics can be traced even further back in the region’s history which, according to Clampitt, abounds with ingenuity and determination. 

In 1787, the Northwest Ordinance opened up the Midwest to new governance, and those who moved to the territory had few guiding regulations. Upon arrival, they navigated forests filled with wild predators and rising tensions with Native Americans. In short, moving to the Midwest was not for the faint of heart. 

“The majority of people that moved to the Midwest were people who had ambition and vision and created a new country,” Clampitt said. 

This spirit continued in the Midwest to the 19th and 20th centuries when the region became a hotspot for immigration. 

In the 1800s, European immigrants from Greece, Germany, England and Nordic countries flocked to states like Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan and the Dakotas to make a new life for themselves. These immigrants brought with them flavors from their home countries, which mixed with regional ingredients to create wholly Midwestern dishes. 

Cincinnati Chili is a prime example. The city’s staple dish consists of meat and tomato stew spiced with cinnamon, clove and allspice. The resulting mixture is served on a bed of spaghetti and topped with cheddar cheese. 

The dish can be traced back to Greek immigrant brothers Tom and John Kiradjieff, who owned a struggling Cincinnati restaurant called Empress in 1922. They came up with the famed dish in hopes of increasing business. 

The Kiradjieff brothers were vaguely aware of chili but unfamiliar with how the food was typically served. So, they filled in the blanks by incorporating their Macedonian roots. The final product is reminiscent of pastitsio, a Greek dish of layered pasta and spiced meat with a cheesy bechamel sauce. 

The new menu addition was a hit. The dish’s popularity brought an influx of diners to the Empress, and some employees even set out to create their own versions of the chili. People’s fondness for the mix of Tex-Mex and Macedonian flavors cemented Cincinnati Chili as a local favorite. 

A few decades after the Kiradjieff brothers enthralled Cincinnattians with their chili recipe, a different “odd” food was taking the Midwest by storm: Jell-O. 

Jell-O Salads have established themselves as a classic contributor to Midwestern potlucks, church lunches and funeral receptions. These “salads” take various forms — ranging from a ring of ruby red strawberry Jell-O layered with cream cheese to cubes of vegetables and ham suspended in a mountain of clear gelatin

In the early 1800s, gelatin was a food reserved for the wealthiest of households. Making gelatin required a lengthy process of boiling down animal bones and connective tissues, straining the liquid, waiting until all the fat rose to the top and skimming that layer off. Serving gelatin meant the host had the time and the kitchen staff to complete the arduous task. 

Flavored instant gelatin first entered the home cooking scene in 1897. Clampitt explained that given the ingredient’s elite history, instant gelatin was widely considered a genius novelty. 

“When Jell-O first came out with gelatin, it was like ‘Oh my gosh. We can eat like kings,” she said. 

Jell-O molds became a centerpiece (both literally and figuratively) of posh dinner parties in the Midwest. Other foods involving instant gelatin like Watergate Salad — a mixture of canned pineapples, pistachio pudding, Cool Whip and mini marshmallows — and its various counterparts made their way into the repertoires of home cooks.

In truth, Jello-O was a fan favorite all across the United States, showing up in dining rooms and church halls in the Northeastern and Southern states as well. Similarly, desperation pies were a common food strategy anywhere ingredients were scarce, and hotdishes were once a food of reason for anyone with a low budget.

Midwestern food has been squeezed out of resourcefulness during harsh economic situations and born of enthusiasm for culinary innovations and — in the case of Cincinnati Chili — cultural diversity. The region’s food is a result not of its peculiar character but rather its honest history.

Despite its reputation, the reality may be that Midwestern cuisine is not strange after all — or at least no stranger than any other regional cuisine.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here