Here’s What ‘The Paper’ Creators Greg Daniels and Michael Koman Think About Toledo, Ohio

“The Paper,” the spinoff mockumentary series to “The Office,” launched its first season in September. We talked to creators Greg Daniels and Michael Koman to find out why they set the show in Toledo — and what they thought about the Glass City.

Toledo, Ohio, has become the new Scranton, Pennsylvania, since “The Paper’s” early September release. 

“The Office” spinoff follows the same mockumentary crew that has now relocated to a declining Midwestern newspaper, the Toledo Truth Teller. 

Creators Greg Daniels — who developed “The Office” 20 years ago — and Michael Koman selected the Glass City for its catchy name and established reputation. A local ramen restaurant might have helped, too. 

Midstory spoke with Daniels and Koman about Toledo and the Midwest. 

This interview has been lightly edited for length and clarity.


Q: Why is ‘The Paper’ set in Toledo?

Greg Daniels: I hate to say this, but it’s really because of the alliteration of “Toledo Truth Teller.” And it just sounded like a cool old newspaper. 

Michael Koman: It’s also with a lot of history. It was the Glass City. It was a city that you can visualize really easily in the 19th century, early 20th century, thriving in a lot of different ways. It has a lot of character, but it’s going through a fairly difficult time, sort of the way that Scranton was in the other show. 

Daniels: As a name, it punches above its weight in the national awareness in the way that people have heard of Scranton, Pennsylvania, and they’ve heard of Toledo, Ohio, more than they might have heard of Gary, Indiana, or something like that.

Q: What aspects of Toledo made you want to set the show there?

Koman: Ohio, where it is, is one thing. And it’s a city that actually has a history with newspapers. 

Daniels: This notion of what they call ghost newspapers is not actually in Toledo. Toledo has a great, thriving newspaper, The Blade. But other places in the Midwest have situations where a company will come, they’ll buy a small newspaper, they’ll get rid of the reporters, they’ll just put wire services in, and they’ll keep the ad salespeople. It looks like the community still has a newspaper, but it doesn’t, really, because there aren’t any local reporters. We thought that’s a really interesting topic for our fictional documentary crew to be interested in. 

Q: What other cities did you consider besides Toledo?

Daniels: I considered other cities that began with ‘T,’ so I considered Tempe and Tucson and Tallahassee. We went to Toledo to do research, and it felt good there. It seemed like there was a lot of public art in Toledo that we were excited to see. 

Koman: When you were asking a question about ‘Why Toledo,’ I want it to sound like there’s this deeply considered reason, but I think a lot of it’s emotional. If you see the city and it feels right, you can kind of visualize the show taking place there. 

I liked that I can picture boats going by on a river, when somebody’s looking out their office window, and they’re looking at the city, and they’re imagining, they’re thinking of what’s going on. And to me, it just has something to do with trade and commerce, like why you build a city in a certain kind of place at a certain time. A lot of them were built when boats brought things to the city, and that’s how you needed to get things there. 

And now things have changed, but the city’s still there, so it needs to figure out a way to do business today, and that I just kind of find interesting. When I say personality, I guess that’s what I mean by it.

Daniels: Also, our hotel had a big exhibit about Jamie Farr and the “M*A*S*H” TV show in the lobby when we were there. That felt like good karma, and that was a wonderful show.

Q: Some of the cities that you mentioned are not in the Midwest. Why did you pick the Midwest?

Daniels: One of the reasons why Toledo won out is the actual stories about regional journalism we’re looking at took place in the Midwest, mostly. Florida’s got a different vibe in the national consciousness. If you set it in Tallahassee, I just think that there would be other things that Florida is known for, and California, probably the same. People have a lot of opinions about California that are highly flavored the way they are about Florida, but Ohio has got a nice balance to it. 

Koman: You hear about it so much during elections. This is an important state in that way, and it feels like a state where people kind of have to figure out how to get along because people have very different opinions there. It’s not a uniform state, and I think that’s also attractive.

Q: What put Toledo on your radar? 

Daniels: That’s what I meant about punching above its weight. Toledo’s got about 250,000 people, but very much everyone’s heard of it in the whole country. But I think if you were to go to another state — I don’t think anybody has as strong an opinion about Bloomington, for instance, or maybe would even know what state it’s in. 

Koman: A big thing is just that it has a snappy name. Toledo is a name that rolls off your tongue, and I think that’s the reason why, since the beginning, since radio, it’s just a name that people use as a quick choice. It’s the same reason Bugs Bunny went to Albuquerque. It has this kind of music to it, and that is, in a weird way, more significant than you’d think.

Daniels: When you just make it into sounds, it’s like ba-dum-bum. To-le-do. 

Koman: Also, it conjures a picture. There are a lot of cities, you could say the name to somebody, and you just get a blank. But if you say Toledo, I think there’s a little bit of an image that a person gets in their head. It doesn’t necessarily mean it’s an accurate one, but they’re familiar with the idea of what you’re talking about, and I think that’s a big help. 

Daniels: When I was doing “The Office,” we had other branches of Dunder Mifflin. There was the Scranton branch, but there was also a branch in Yonkers. There was a branch in Nashua. We spent a lot of time rolling the names around on the tongue to figure out what would be, what would be a tasty branch area. And I think if we had thought that the company was big enough to get into Ohio, Toledo would have been a prime Dunder Mifflin branch, just for the way it sounds. 

Koman: We visited Toledo at one point, and on my way out, my last thing I did there was have lunch at a ramen place, and it was one of the best ramens I’ve ever had in my life. It was so delicious, and I just thought, ‘Oh, I didn’t expect that. I was wrong.’ 

Something about that just made me feel like there’s more to this place than I would assume. So that means that I can’t go in there with a bunch of preconceived notions. It’s just like any place else, but it’s just full of interesting people. I like that you go in with preconceived notions that you can then lose and find something new past them.

Q: Do you remember what the ramen place was called?

Koman: I think it was called Kato. That whole area of that street, it was such a nice surprise. I love that area.

1 COMMENT

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here